Since 2000, I have been testing a hypothesis that our traditional Westminster-derived model is under strain. My instincts have long been that we are beyond Westminster. To evaluate that hypothesis, I use the framework in Rhodes, Wanna and Weller’s Comparing Westminster (2009), from which I take five elements: parliamentary sovereignty, an opposition recognised as an…

Since 2000, I have been testing a hypothesis that our traditional Westminster-derived model is under strain. My instincts are that we are beyond Westminster. To evaluate that hypothesis, I use the framework in Rhodes, Wanna and Weller’s Comparing Westminster (2009), from which I take five elements: parliamentary sovereignty, an opposition recognised as an executive-in-waiting, collective…

For the last quarter-century, I’ve examined the hypothesis that Aotearoa’s Westminster-derived governance model is under increasing strain. The traditional pressure points remain relevant: the shift to mixed-member-proportional representation, evolving foreign policy alliances affecting parliamentary sovereignty, expanded use of associate ministers and undersecretaries, coalition dynamics challenging cabinet solidarity, inadequate regulatory scrutiny, and the growing influence of…

As we enter the third year of examining our governance model’s evolution, the central hypothesis remains: Aotearoa’s Westminster-derived system continues to show significant signs of strain. While most indicators remain consistent with last year’s assessment, two shifts warrant attention. First, there’s a marked decline in the Cabinet’s narrative capability. Despite considerable activity and policy implementation,…

A year ago, I posited that Aotearoa’s Westminster-derived governance model showed signs of systemic strain. The identified pressure points were numerous and significant: the transition to mixed-member-proportional representation, the expanded use of associate ministers and parliamentary undersecretaries, the integration of non-government ministers into the Cabinet, the frequent threats to cabinet solidarity by coalition partners, inadequate…

Aotearoa’s political and administrative landscape is undergoing a profound transformation that challenges its Westminster foundations. Multiple forces are driving this evolution: the complex dynamics of a post-colonial state, a hollowed-out public service increasingly reliant on non-state actors for delivery, and political parties struggling to attract high-calibre talent for senior positions. The strain on our traditional…