I close the series by setting out what the findings mean for guidance and capability in Aotearoa, where the study reaches its limits, and how the puzzle that opened the thesis looks once free and frank advice is read as a bounded plurality. This is the last of twenty posts drawn from my doctoral thesis…
Read moreI explain how the study found Te Tiriti o Waitangi at the edge of the bounded plurality, how I interpret that limit, and why I mark it as the constitutional limit of the mapped domain instead of adding a seventh posture. This is the nineteenth of twenty posts drawn from my doctoral thesis on free…
Read moreI argue that offering and listening to free and frank advice is political work of an astute and professional kind, set out where astuteness ends and politicisation begins, and ask what follows for political neutrality. This is the eighteenth of twenty posts drawn from my doctoral thesis on free and frank advice in Aotearoa. In…
Read moreI explain why free and frank advice remains undefined, drawing on the essentially contested concept, the remainder and agonism to argue that a definition would take a side in the contest it claimed to referee. This is the seventeenth of twenty posts drawn from my doctoral thesis on free and frank advice in Aotearoa. In…
Read moreI read the six postures beside their nearest analogues in the scholarship on advice and the public service, and argue that they are situated enactments of tradition, orientations a practitioner takes up for a situation, which travel across office and belong to neither role nor personality. This is the sixteenth of twenty posts drawn from…
Read moreI bring the six postures, practical statecraft and the four fault lines together as the bounded plurality finding, explain why I treat it as a sensitising concept rather than a definition, and set out why Aotearoa’s constitutional culture makes an undefined convention workable. This is the fifteenth of twenty posts drawn from my doctoral thesis…
Read moreI describe the shape of the six-posture solution and the four fault lines that run through it, over mandate, challenge, occasion and timing, and I explain why each one persists as a dilemma rather than a mistake one side is making. This is the fourteenth of twenty posts drawn from my doctoral thesis on free…
Read moreI describe the last three of the six postures in my thesis, the Moment Chooser, the Political Servant and the Westminster Protector, and explain why two of them were retained on a single defining sort and what they add to the map. This is the thirteenth of twenty posts drawn from my doctoral thesis on…
Read moreI set out what the six practitioner postures in my thesis hold in common, the four statements that recur across them, and the two-part test I call practical statecraft, which practitioners used to tell free and frank advice from advice that only resembles it. This is the eleventh of twenty posts drawn from my doctoral…
Read moreI explain how the Q-sort revealed a structure in the way practitioners hold free and frank advice, and I describe the first three of the six postures: the Institutional Pragmatist, the Democratic Constitutionalist and the Collaborative Sense-Maker. This is the twelfth of twenty posts drawn from my doctoral thesis on free and frank advice in…
Read moreI report the first stage of my thesis research, the six domains through which practitioners talked about free and frank advice, and how that material was reduced to the 34 statements later sorted in Stage Two. This is the tenth of twenty posts drawn from my doctoral thesis on free and frank advice in Aotearoa,…
Read moreI explain how Āta shaped the research relationships in my thesis, what being an insider-Indigenous researcher gave the inquiry and asked of it, and how confidentiality was protected in a small senior public service. This is the ninth of twenty posts drawn from my doctoral thesis on free and frank advice in Aotearoa. The previous…
Read moreI explain why my thesis studies free and frank advice as practitioner meaning, how Q-methodology tests whether that meaning is shared, and how the three-stage design and its analytical decisions worked. This is the eighth of twenty posts drawn from my doctoral thesis on free and frank advice in Aotearoa. Having shown that neither the…
Read moreI read four decades of scholarship on free and frank advice as three dispositions, set out the three things the map leaves out, and explain why the conditions of the convention are mapped while its meaning is not. This is the seventh of twenty posts drawn from my doctoral thesis on free and frank advice…
Read moreI follow free and frank advice into the Public Service Act 2020 and its 2026 amendment, and I set out the pattern of elaboration without definition that runs across four decades of statute. This is the sixth of twenty posts drawn from my doctoral thesis on free and frank advice in Aotearoa. Having followed the…
Read moreI look at how the Official Information Act 1982 first brought free and frank advice into statute as an interest protected from disclosure, how widely that protection reaches, and what it left undefined. This is the fourth of twenty posts drawn from my doctoral thesis on free and frank advice in Aotearoa. In this post…
Read moreI trace the four layers through which free and frank advice reached Aotearoa, from the Westminster frame and the Whitehall service to Te Tiriti o Waitangi and the Public Service Act 1912, and show how the conditions beneath each Westminster assumption have since shifted. This is the third of twenty posts drawn from my doctoral…
Read moreI compare how Australia, the United Kingdom, Canada and Aotearoa carry the obligation of candid advice, and I argue that beneath four different arrangements the four systems share one silence about what that obligation requires. This is the second of twenty posts drawn from my doctoral thesis on free and frank advice in Aotearoa. In…
Read moreI open the series by setting out the puzzle my thesis began with, that free and frank advice is written into statute and invoked across the public service while nobody has said what it means, and I outline what I found. This is the first of twenty posts drawn from my doctoral thesis on free…
Read moreMore heat than light: IPANZ contributions to the free and frank advice discussion (2024) In this 2024 analysis for Public Sector, I trace the contribution the Institute of Public Administration New Zealand has made over a decade to the discussion of free and frank advice, a subject that attracts considerable commentary but little empirical work…
Read moreI wrote this as an observation on the new free and frank advice principle in the Public Service Act 2020. Parliament had elevated free and frank advice to a principle without saying what it means, and I was worried about what the unintended consequences would be. The practice of courage is an important trait for…
Read moreIn this post I set out what I have learned about giving free and frank advice that busy decision-makers want to keep hearing: have something to say, say it well, and remember whose table you are sitting at. Advisers need to keep in mind that ministers, politicians and boards are in a hurry, because they…
Read more