Beyond Westminster? 2022 Edition Hineraumati

12/12/2022

As we enter the third year of examining our governance model’s evolution, the central hypothesis remains: Aotearoa-New Zealand’s Westminster-derived system continues to show significant signs of strain. While most indicators remain consistent with last year’s assessment, two notable shifts warrant attention.

First, there’s a marked decline in the Cabinet’s narrative capability. Despite considerable activity and policy implementation, the government appears unable to articulate a coherent story about its achievements or direction. This communication vacuum is compounded by visible ministerial fatigue, suggesting deeper systemic issues beyond mere messaging challenges.

In parallel, we’re witnessing the emergence of a more credible opposition. The Leader of the Opposition and deputy have successfully crafted a focused narrative centred on three key themes: cost of living pressures, economic development, and public service delivery failures. Their message discipline and energy starkly contrast the incumbent government’s communication struggles and appear to be gaining public traction.

The public service assessment remains orange, with persistent concerns about institutional capacity and effectiveness. The continued outsourcing of core policy work to consultancies suggests an ongoing hollowing out of internal capability. Equally troubling is the failure of officials to effectively manage community engagement and expectations in policy development processes. A new and significant criticism has emerged from the infrastructure sector, whose leaders argue that the machinery of government (te poneketanga) lacks the structural capacity to enable their success.

These developments suggest we’re not merely witnessing temporary strains on our Westminster model but potentially observing its fundamental transformation. The question is increasingly not whether we’re moving beyond Westminster but what we’re moving toward.

Nau mai haere mai Hine Raumati. He iti tangata e tupu – he iti toki e iti tonu.

Download

Disclaimer

These are my evolving thoughts, rhetorical positions and creative provocations. They are not settled conclusions. Content should not be taken as professional advice, official statements or final positions. I reserve the right to learn, unlearn, rethink and grow. If you’re here to sort me neatly into left vs right, keep moving. I’m not the partisan you’re looking for. These in...

Ahakoa he iti kete, he iti nā te a …

Kia ora, and welcome I’m starting a blog. I’m as surprised as you are. This is a place to jot down my evolving thoughts about public administration, policy, and delivery in Aotearoa: beneath the surface and between the relays of elected and unelected officials. It will be about the undercurrents. Not the tired critiques or the glossy promises, but the patterns, tensions, compromises,...

The First Four

Before I begin, I want to mihi to Hon Shane Jones. In the House yesterday, he reminded us of the first four rangatira who first stepped into Parliament on behalf of Māori. He did more than recite names: he called us to remember them properly, to see them as political actors who helped shape the country. In 1868, four Māori leaders: Frederick Nene Russell, Wiremu Katene, John Patterson, an...

Getting Regulation Right: Being Res …

Regulation often gets a mixed reputation. Some see it as unnecessary red tape, slowing things down and making life harder for businesses and communities. Others worry that it's too weak and fails to properly protect people and the environment. What both views have in common is frustration with regulation that seems disconnected from the real world. But good regulation doesn't have...

Was I Too Quick to Judge the Nine Q …

I was pretty critical of the last government for refusing to name outcome areas or set any shared targets for the public management system. They didn’t want to be pinned down. They said it was about flexibility and complexity, but in practice, it made it hard to know what mattered, who was responsible, or what success even looked like. And most importantly, in today’s always-on political e...