Free and Frank Advice and being a good guest

1/2/2021

Suppose you are working in public policy right now.

In that case, you will know that the most precious commodity is not information – information is abundant.

Nor is it knowledge – there is an oversupply of competent advisers – many of whom have a strong opinion or a long-held view and are confident in their advice.

The most valuable commodity is time.

The ‘future’ in public policy is four years at its longest point on the horizon, and probably three years if one is honest. And, every day spent sitting in meetings with 20-page power-point decks is one day shorter from that horizon.

Advisers need to keep in mind that ministers, politicians and boards are in a hurry. They are busy people. Combine their pace and engagement with the fact that most of them have many sources of advice, which means they are better plugged into the ‘real world’ than many of their belt-way advisers.

My personal experience is that the best ministers, politicians, and boards would rather hear the bad news and unhappy reports, so long as the advice is well-reasoned, supported by data and argument, and presented without rancour, value judgments, or arrogance.

Suppose you want your advice to be part of the routine and rhythm of key decision-makers. In that case, you need to have something to say. It needs to add value to the role and strategy the decision-makers have outlined and be a product that those same people cannot get anywhere else.

You also have to be mindful of how you deliver your product.

The best public policy advisers are humble enough to recognise they are optional extras. They are guests at someone else’s dinner party. And, like any guest who wants to be invited back, they don’t get drunk and spill the wine, they don’t insult the host or criticise the menu or the food, and they don’t overstay their welcome.

Remember, public policy, after all, arises in a political context – not just an administrative or managerial one.

Be a good guest.

Ma whero. Ma pango. Ka oti ai te mahi.

Disclaimer

These are my evolving thoughts, rhetorical positions and creative provocations. They are not settled conclusions. Content should not be taken as professional advice, official statements or final positions. I reserve the right to learn, unlearn, rethink and grow. If you’re here to sort me neatly into left vs right, keep moving. I’m not the partisan you’re looking for. These in...

Ahakoa he iti kete, he iti nā te a …

Kia ora, and welcome I’m starting a blog. I’m as surprised as you are. This is a place to jot down my evolving thoughts about public administration, policy, and delivery in Aotearoa: beneath the surface and between the relays of elected and unelected officials. It will be about the undercurrents. Not the tired critiques or the glossy promises, but the patterns, tensions, compromises,...

Time to Retire “Bad Apples …

A plea from Ōtautahi. Can we stop using the phrase "bad apples" when discussing institutional problems? It is a tired cliché that has outlived whatever usefulness it might have once had. The idiom "one bad apple spoils the whole barrel" initially warned about how quickly rot spreads. Yet in contemporary discussions about institutional accountability, we've flipped its meaning to isolate and ...

Getting Regulation Right: Being Res …

Regulation often gets a mixed reputation. Some see it as unnecessary red tape, slowing things down and making life harder for businesses and communities. Others worry that it's too weak and fails to properly protect people and the environment. What both views have in common is frustration with regulation that seems disconnected from the real world. But good regulation doesn't have...

The Implosion of the US Administrat …

The collapse of the US administrative state is not just an American problem, it carries important lessons for Aotearoa New Zealand. As Washington grapples with political dysfunction and the erosion of public institutions, we should pay attention to how a weakened state apparatus invites economic instability, political turmoil, and diminished democratic control. For Aotearoa New Zealand, th...