Trust in public services in on the decline

1/8/2024

Trust in public services is on the decline.

This particular measure calls attention to a measure of ‘trust’ as the state is not doing harm.

In addition, confidence in public services – due to an actual experience – is flatlining.

A follower on blue-sky asked me why I didn’t comment on the private sector comparator.

My answer to them was in two parts.

First, the public and private sectors are alike except in the most essential respects. Unlike in the private sector, we have little, if any, choice in dealing with officials and agencies—good or bad. They are monopolies.

Second, I am not confident that “experiences” capture the transactions where the state uses its most coercive powers. I think that should be the “experiences” test, not whether someone got their passport on time.

I might in the future, though.

The Edelman Trust Barometer is starting to reveal some interesting data about how people see the role of the private sector.

In short, the private sector is now more trusted than the public sector, and businesses are being encouraged to leverage this comparative advantage to inform debate and deliver solutions on some of the more significant public policy issues.

Disclaimer

These are my evolving thoughts, rhetorical positions and creative provocations. They are not settled conclusions. Content should not be taken as professional advice, official statements or final positions. I reserve the right to learn, unlearn, rethink and grow. If you’re here to sort me neatly into left vs right, keep moving. I’m not the partisan you’re looking for. These in...

Waitangi Tribunal Thursdays

The Pattern So Far I've been away for a week or so, catching my breath after wrapping up a couple of big projects. I found my way back through music: last week’s theme was Massive Attack. I can’t lie, "Unfinished Sympathy" on repeat is my happy place. That slow-building track that starts sparse and grows into something enormous, where every element matters and nothing is wasted. The st...

Waitangi Tribunal Thursdays: Wai 5

Two quiet pages that echo today E te rangatira, Tarsh Kemp, moe mai rā i te moenga roa. Haere atu rā ki te huihuinga o te kahurangi, ki te kāhui o ngā mātua tūpuna. Ko tō reo i ngā whare kōrero, ko tō ūpoko pakaru mō te iwi Māori, ko tō ūmanga mō te tika me te pono: e kore e mimiti i te mahara. I mārama koe ki te whawhai mō te tino rangatiratanga – he nui ōna mata, he ...

Waitangi Tribunal Thursdays: WAI 8

From advisory state to advisory system In 1983, the number one song in the world was "Every Breath You Take" by The Police. Often mistaken for romantic, the song is unmistakably about surveillance, control, and possession: a chilling refrain that echoed the mood of 1983 far more than most listeners realised. Around the world, 1983 was the year of heightened surveillance anxieties: from ...