Thought blooms, but spoken words blossom

1/1/2018

Okay, as 2017 ends, I am finally able to my doctorate from Victoria University of Wellington to the University of Canterbury. One advisor said to me, “the only PhD is a completed one”. I will blog another time about what it was like studying at Victoria University of Wellington.

In the meantime, this post summarises my inquiry. More to come.

In 1859 John Stuart Mill proposed that the constraint on free speech emerged at the point at which a person incites violence. My PhD is looking at what that point is for free and frank advice. In the case of free speech, we are not entitled to shout “fire’ in a crowded theatre. My PhD asks: at what point do senior public servants constrain their advice, why, and what does this tell us about the elements of free and frank advice?

I have spent much of my career reflecting on this question. When I started out as a policy advisor in 1995, I thought free and frank advice lay in the idea of sovereignty – the right of decision-makers to have access to all the information to make good public policy decisions.

After nearly twenty-two years as a public policy advisor and manager, I think it is more nuanced.

I think free and frank advice has to consider the interests of the speaker and the audience and the empirical considerations arising from the risk that advice is fallible, and advisers are not always right.

This is because policy advice is not without costs: poor policy advice causes damage, can disclose personal and harmful information and is not risk-free.

Words matter. Speech matters. Advice matters.

And, because it matters, it is essential that Governments and senior officials who want to regulate free and frank advice, for example, to prevent things that would be embarrassing to politicians or otherwise upset the Government, should have that power of regulation carefully circumscribed and reviewed.

Now it’s time to see if I can get into Canterbury.

Ka hua te whakaaro, Ka hua te kōrero.

Disclaimer

These are my evolving thoughts, rhetorical positions and creative provocations. They are not settled conclusions. Content should not be taken as professional advice, official statements or final positions. I reserve the right to learn, unlearn, rethink and grow. If you’re here to sort me neatly into left vs right, keep moving. I’m not the partisan you’re looking for. These in...

Ahakoa he iti kete, he iti nā te a …

Kia ora, and welcome I’m starting a blog. I’m as surprised as you are. This is a place to jot down my evolving thoughts about public administration, policy, and delivery in Aotearoa: beneath the surface and between the relays of elected and unelected officials. It will be about the undercurrents. Not the tired critiques or the glossy promises, but the patterns, tensions, compromises,...

Time to Retire “Bad Apples …

A plea from Ōtautahi. Can we stop using the phrase "bad apples" when discussing institutional problems? It is a tired cliché that has outlived whatever usefulness it might have once had. The idiom "one bad apple spoils the whole barrel" initially warned about how quickly rot spreads. Yet in contemporary discussions about institutional accountability, we've flipped its meaning to isolate and ...

Getting Regulation Right: Being Res …

Regulation often gets a mixed reputation. Some see it as unnecessary red tape, slowing things down and making life harder for businesses and communities. Others worry that it's too weak and fails to properly protect people and the environment. What both views have in common is frustration with regulation that seems disconnected from the real world. But good regulation doesn't have...

The Implosion of the US Administrat …

The collapse of the US administrative state is not just an American problem, it carries important lessons for Aotearoa New Zealand. As Washington grapples with political dysfunction and the erosion of public institutions, we should pay attention to how a weakened state apparatus invites economic instability, political turmoil, and diminished democratic control. For Aotearoa New Zealand, th...