Journal Article: Provoking Debate and Learning Lessons
05/11/2012
Provoking debate and learning lessons: What the Performance Improvement Framework challenged us to think about (2012)
In this 2012 article, Kevin Guerin and I ask what the first 21 Performance Improvement Framework reviews, published in the framework’s first three years, suggest about public management in Aotearoa when they are read together as a single data set. We set out what the framework is, why the central agencies introduced it in 2009, and the limits on aggregating ratings that were designed as contextual judgements rather than comparable scores. Read with those limits in mind, the reviews tend to show that agencies deliver well on what ministers ask of them, with engagement with ministers and financial management rated strongest. By contrast, purpose, vision and strategy, the management of people performance, information management and efficiency rate lowest. We also find that results and capability are positively associated, that agency size makes little difference to performance, and that agencies with a clear purpose and aligned structures tend to achieve stronger results. We connect these findings to the Better Public Services programme and the four-year excellence horizon. We conclude that integrity is necessary but not sufficient for public trust and confidence, and that much of the work of demonstrating consistent performance across the state sector was still ahead of the central agencies and senior leaders.
Read the article: https://doi.org/10.26686/pq.v8i4.4430
Reference
Te Kawa, D., & Guerin, K. (2012). Provoking debate and learning lessons: It is early days, but what does the Performance Improvement Framework challenge us to think about? Policy Quarterly, 8(4), 28–36. https://doi.org/10.26686/pq.v8i4.4430
ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0006-5129-5218
DownloadLoose Threads: What the Spirit of S …
Read through the interpretive hinge In May I wrote here about a photograph of New York’s mayor on the W train, and about how seldom our own political conversation celebrates the daily work of public officials rather than treating it with suspicion. I argued that the work of celebration is itself a joyful constitutional act, that we have the apparatus for it but are somewhat sh...
Read moreAdministrative Burden: The Woman …
I look at how the unpaid labour of dealing with the state falls for the most part on women, drawing on Herd and Moynihan’s theory of gendered burden and on what raising a child in Aotearoa demands of mothers. This is the fourth post in a series about what it actually costs to navigate the state. Last month I examined how burdens fall hardest on the least resourced, and I introduced t...
Read morePanel: The Māori Crown relationshi …
The Māori–Crown relationship: The why, the who, and the howPublic Sector, Spring 2026 I joined Helmut Modlik, Chief Executive of Te Rūnanga o Toa Rangatira, and Steven Sutton on a panel at the Hāpai Public Aspiring Senior Leaders Masterclass, a workshop for tier three and four managers on the relationship between Māori and the Crown. I argued that for nearly 200 years Te Tiriti o Waitang...
Read more